Musical Box Reviews

Also see: Genesis

Date: Fri, 27 Feb 2004 13:09:56 -0500 From: Bill Fox <> Subject: Musical Box
Greetings, I went out last night with some friends to a concert. But my EMUSIC radio show airs on Thursday at 11:04 pm. I solved the conflict by prerecording my show and having a friend play the tape. Not knowing what time I'd arrive home, I never expected to hear myself on the radio the way everyone else hears me. What a strange feeling! BTW, the concert that drew me away from EMUSIC was The Musical Box, a Genesis tribute band. They did a show from the Selling England By the Pound tour. They put me into instant gratification space by starting with Watcher of the Skies. And it only got better from there. They had the set, slides, light show, costumes, and music perfectly recreated! The singer had Peter's manerisms and between-song stories, a recreation you must see if you're a fan of early prog. If you never saw Peter Gabriel-era Genesis, you still can by catching the Musical Box in concert. And they have none of the technical difficulties that Genesis experienced. Oh yes, the FOH mixer does a great job and at a reasonable volume level.

From: "Grant Penton" <>
Can I get in a plug for the MUSICAL BOX? The best classic Genesis cover band, everyone should see 'em-

From: "Robertson, Scott" <>
For those of us who were not fortunate enough to catch Genesis in the early years, there is an alternative. As Grant Penton mentioned, The Musical Box is quite an experience. For those who may not be aware, The Musical Box is for lack of better terms, a "Tribute" band for Genesis. The biggest point to make is that they completely replicate Genesis concerts. From the stage design, to lighting, to PG's costuming and gestures...all the way through has been painstakingly reproduced from actual films of Genesis performances. The musicianship is incredibly accurate. The equipment is the original models so that the sound can be accurately reproduced. Even PG's dialog between songs is replicated. Two weeks ago, I trekked from Cincinnati to Montreal to catch their final performance of "Selling England" tour. I still have yet to put the experience to words. For the first time hearing Watcher of the Skies, Supper's Ready and Firth of Fifth live was incredible. It was very difficult to remind myself that this was not Genesis playing. After a 15 hour drive, a 4 hour detention at Canadian Customs (a long story, but legal), it was worth it just to see/hear The Musical Box. Their Web site is x. Catch them if you can! They revived a lot of memories of the early Genesis years and brought back to me some of the "Progressive" music that I had been lacking.

From: Rob <>
>Their website is great, but in major need of an update...they have no dates listed after Spring '98. Anyone know if they're planning to hit the USA this year?
They didn't perform any shows between Spring '98 and their final Selling England show on 14 November in Montreal, as far as I know. Having retired their entire repertoire, they are either no longer a band or are working on a Lamb show.... personally I couldn't care less what a show looks like as long as they play something from my record collection really well, but I do regret having missed TMB because they did play early Genesis really well.

From: joelkru@aol.com  I've just returned from Montreal after having seen both Saturday evening performances of Genesis' "Selling England By The Pound" by The Musical Box. IMO, quite an odd experience. I drove up from Connecticut with some friends. While Waiting in line we ran into folks who had flown in from Indiana and California. These guys have some serious fans. (They don't perfrom very often.) It's one thing to see a tribute band who plays a particular band's music. It's quite another to see a group of people present what ends up being a theatrical re-creation of an actual Genesis concert. Every note was in place, the set was identical to the original, and the gentleman who "played" Peter Gabriel, other than being of a slightly heavier build than the slim Gabriel of the time in his black jumpsuit, was quite fascinating. Not only did he sound like PG of that era, including the surreal stories between the songs, but he bore quite the resemblence to him facially as well. I still have reservations about why a show of this type exists at all. Granted, I truely enjoyed hearing this music live, particularly the breathtaking "Watcher Of The Skies" which opened the show, but there was something scratching around at the back of my mind which would not let me transcend the fact that these folks, for all their facility, were not Genesis. Then again, this is about as close as anyone could actually being able to experience a classic band such as this live. (Genesismania?) They even gave out promotional CDs which feature live tracks from their shows in November of '98. Is it real or is it Generex?

[www.e-prog.net]